Skip to content

UK and Italian Reports on ‘Bayesian’ Sinking Differ Widely

On Wednesday we wrote that the Italian investigation of the Bayesian sinking had determined the cause was a negligent crew. On Wednesday we read in The Guardian that the cause was the fault of the builder and the inaccurate weather forecasting. The article stated that the UK’s Marine Accident Investigations Branch (MAIB) had concluded that the information contained in guidance provided to the crew would not have warned them of the impact of possible weather conditions that could affect stability while at anchor. They also said the weather forecast did not indicate the risk of downbursts or severe winds from the predicted thunderstorms.

The Bayesian was designed as a ketch rig but the original owner wanted a sloop version.
Bayesian was built by Perini Navi to a design that originally called for a ketch rig, but the original owner wanted the tall mast of a sloop.
© 2026 Wikipedia / Wikicommons

Like so many other accidents, there are numerous “what-ifs” or “if-onlys” that might have prevented this terrible tragedy. If only the weather forecast had been more accurate, if only the crew had been told the keel should be kept down while at anchor, if only the crew had closed that hatch, or if only the megayacht owner had been content with the smaller masts in the original design, or if only the builder had talked the owner out of a single, ultra-tall mast on the boat.

There is a lot to be learned from accident investigations on any vessel sinking, especially one with loss of life. There are a surprising number of megayachts that have sunk over the years, though no mishap reminds us to be humble when facing Mother Nature more than the Titanic.

The report from the Italian investigation states that Bayesian’s sinking was the fault of the crew. The UK accident report believes it was a combination of an inadequate weather report and poor instructions from the builder to the crew that would have let them know that the boat could sink while at anchor when faced with heavy winds. Perini Navi built 10 boats of this model, though nine of them were built as ketches, and Bayesian was the only one built as a sloop. Bayesian was built in Italy by Perini Navi and the captain was from New Zealand.

 

2 Comments

  1. Ken Brinkley 3 hours ago

    Hindsight is always 20/20. Hubris played a large role as it does in many tragedies . The need to place blame is strong . But the Swiss cheese analogy is first and foremost a reality check. When the holes line up ,the odds Are not in our favor . Condolences to the survivors and yes lessons can be learned .Looking for a scapegoat is always counterproductive.

  2. Mark Darley 58 minutes ago

    And a very experienced captain he was too.
    No surprise that the Italian findings did not find the yard at fault. This incident has already been very damaging to their ship building industry. Now the yard is suing for reputational harm.
    Try comparing that to losing members of your family, and as captain, losing your career as a result of a yacht designed with instability faults.

Leave a Comment