Oracle Nipped by One Second – and Two
Penalties
January 15 – Auckland, NZ
Yesterday’s third Louis Vuitton Finals
race between Oracle BMW and the seemingly invincible Alinghi
couldn’t have been more exciting. Trailing 2-0, Larry Ellison
was off the boat as 17th man, Peter Holmberg drove for the start
and the race, and Chris Dickson was back to calling tactics.
Oracle BMW had a 28 second lead at the final of the final downwind
leg, but needed to do a 270º penalty turn. Blessed with
a stronger wind coming down the last leg, Alinghi finished one
second ahead of Oracle, although the latter boat had to do another
penalty turn after drifting into the finish line buoy.

Photo Bob Grieser/Louis Vuitton Cup
The bottom line is that although trailing
3-0 in the best of nine series, Oracle BMW proved that in flat
water conditions at least, they could be as fast or faster than
the Swiss boat. Here’s the more detailed official report of the
race:
“Skipper Chris Dickson and his Oracle
BMW Racing crew came in to the pre-start on the favored starboard
tack, but Alinghi’s Russell Coutts pulled off a masterful start,
positioned upwind of USA-76, with pace, on the favored right
hand side. For the first time in the Louis Vuitton Cup Finals,
Oracle BMW skipper Chris Dickson didn’t take the helm after the
start gun, allowing Peter Holmberg to drive the first weather
leg. Although Coutts converted his impressive start into a controlling
position, USA-76 kept it close and rounded the top mark just
8 seconds back. Holmberg immediately ratcheted up the pressure
by diving down around the mark and setting up slightly lower
and inside Alinghi. Both crews can be commended on beautiful
sets under pressure conditions and the boats started speeding
downwind just a few meters apart. A poor spinnaker drop on USA-76
gave Alinghi a bit more breathing space at the mark rounding.
Early in the second beat, the Swiss enjoyed a solid two length
lead after being overlapped just a couple of minutes before.
Alinghi maintained a lead of 12 seconds around the second top
mark with USA-76 chasing hard a couple of lengths behind. After
the first jibe, Oracle BMW set up nicely to windward and started
to roll over Alinghi. Coutts luffed, and Holmberg responded,
but the American boat was eventually able to break through to
weather and make the pass. A flurry of Y-flag protests followed,
with Dickson claiming Alinghi was sailing above its proper course,
but found no sympathy from the umpires. When Alinghi eventually
jibed, Oracle BMW jibed to leeward, and, now holding luffing
rights, immediately attacked the Swiss boat. The action was extremely
close and Dickson and Holmberg made at least two very strong
attacks with Alinghi desperately avoiding contact. No penalties
were awarded with Alinghi going on to break the overlap. The
frustration on the American boat was evident and Holmberg and
Dickson attacked one last time, the bow on USA-76 coming up and
hitting the stern scoop on Alinghi. The umpires penalized Oracle
BMW for violating Rule 17 (sailing above their proper course).
“Dickson and Holmberg recovered from
that to sail Alinghi out to the starboard jibe layline before
jibing inside and rounding ahead to make the pass, albeit at
the cost of a penalty. USA-76 led Alinghi around a mark for the
first time in this series, with Alinghi 8 seconds behind. On
the final beat, needing to earn enough room to offload the penalty,
Oracle BMW Racing made a nice little gain on the left side early
in the beat, and covered well to stretch away a few crucial boatlengths.
USA-76 made two fewer tacks than Alinghi, and that also added
precious seconds to what would be a 28 second lead around the
final weather mark. The final run was an incredible test for
both boats, with Alinghi trying to close up enough to make a
penalty turn impossible for their opponents. “This is all
about velocity, sailing our boat,” skipper Chris Dickson
told his crew at the start of the leg. While the Oracle BMW crew
strained for every meter it could find, Alinghi, benefiting from
stronger wind behind, followed on its trail. As the finish line
approached, the Swiss crew was able to claw in a few more meters
to put more pressure on the American crew. At the finish line,
the jib went up and the gennaker came down cleanly. Holmberg
spun the boat around the pin end of the finish line, and with
Alinghi charging down under full sail, USA-76 initially looked
as though it might just make it. But after tacking, and needing
to bear away to cross the finish line the boat stalled out, and
Alinghi swept past to take the gun. Meanwhile, Oracle BMW drifted
onto the buoy marking the pin end of the line and copped another
penalty for hitting the mark. The end result, a 1:01 win to Alinghi.”
|